Salutations and National Greetings
Dear General Salim Saleh, Professor Ogenga Otunnu(OO) historian /co-author of the Consociational Democracy Agreement, Academia, CSO, Security chiefs, Cultural. Religious leaders, and fellow Ugandans:
Salaams and warm patriotic greetings from Gulu University, Rotary Clubs of Uganda and the Uganda Red Cross Society (URCS). I extend these greetings on behalf of Quality Education Consultancy Ltd (QECL) and OPUL Skilling Foundation Africa (OSFA), whose motto is “Innovative Skilling as Medicine to Extreme Poverty.” Our long-term ambition is to facilitate 20 million business start-ups, accelerations and innovations, and contribute to creating 40 million decent and sustainable jobs in Africa by 2035.
What is Consociational Democracy Agreement (CDA)?
Dear readers whereas your conversant with CDA,let me refresh your mine, that CDA is a 128-page power-sharing blueprint co-authored by historian Professor OO and General SS (Chief Coordinator of Operation Wealth Creation) to address Uganda’s political, regional, and ethnic divisions. CDA is allegedly focused on addressing the Root Causes and Consequences of Sectarianism, Exclusion, Marginalization and Conflicts in Uganda, the proposal outlines a five-year transitional framework (2026-2031) inspired by consensus-based systems in Switzerland and Belgium to resolve historical, land, and economic divisions.
Despite massive online criticism, I must applaud General SS and Professor OO for daring to bring the military-political chessboard and the academic drawing board into the same room to co-develop the CDA. In a country where politicians sometimes behave like rival cockerels fighting over a single hen while the entire homestead goes hungry, these two have at least attempted to imagine a different national arrangement. As an African proverb reminds us, when two elephants fight, it is the grass that suffers; perhaps the CDA is an attempt to persuade the elephants to negotiate rather than continue trampling the garden. Their initiative deserves intellectual applause for challenging winner-takes-all politics and opening a conversation about reconciliation, inclusive governance and shared national responsibility. Of course, the proposal must survive constitutional scrutiny and public interrogation; otherwise, power-sharing could become nothing more than power-hoarding wearing a democratic necktie! But let us not shoot the messenger merely because we dislike his village: it is easier to criticise the bridge than to attempt crossing the river. Saleh and Otunnu have put an idea on the table; let the nation debate, refine and test it.
The principal gaps and criticisms of the proposed CDA, co-developed by Professor OO and General SS, centre on its legitimacy, inclusiveness, constitutional compatibility, institutional independence, accountability and practical implementation. First, policy analyst, question the credibility of an initiative originating within the ruling establishment, arguing that Saleh’s proximity to the political leadership is simultaneously an advantage and its greatest weakness; he also challenges the proposed Elite Cooperation Chamber, warning that Uganda’s future cannot be negotiated exclusively among political elites. Second, political analyst cautions against reducing consociation democracy to the distribution of government positions and appointments rather than genuine participation in decision-making and the sharing of political power. Third, constitutional lawyers question whether the proposed arrangements can be implemented under the existing constitutional order without appropriate constitutional amendments, parliamentary procedures and public consultation. Fourth, constitutional lawyers further criticises the inadequate consultation of political-party members and the risk of repeating previous secretive NRM-opposition cooperation agreements.
Further criticisms include critical implementation gaps: the proposal does not sufficiently clarify who appoints members of the National Consociational Council, how its grassroots and technical structures will be insulated from government influence, who finances and independently audits them, what legal authority the Council possesses, or what sanctions apply when government fails to honour commitments.Critiques further argue that the CDA must confront contemporary leadership responsibility, constitutionalism, the rule of law, political freedoms and institutional weaknesses rather than attributing Uganda’s divisions predominantly to colonial history. Meanwhile,other critiques demand wider consultation and a national referendum, warning that elite negotiations could undermine multiparty democracy. Collectively, these criticisms suggest that the CDA’s central weakness is not necessarily its aspiration for reconciliation and inclusive governance, but the absence of sufficiently demonstrated guarantees of independent representation, popular consent, enforceable commitments, constitutional legitimacy and protection against elite capture.
What is Diarrhearitizing General SS and why scrambling for the CDA?
I haven’t had discussion with General SS over this subject but his vigorous promotion of the CDA, co-developed with Professor OO, can be interpreted as an attempt to shape Uganda’s political future at a particularly sensitive moment: the question of political succession, the sustainability of the NRM’s four-decade political order, growing public distrust, historical grievances and the challenge of securing a peaceful transition. The succession question is arguably the elephant in the room. Saleh is not an ordinary political broker; his proximity to President Museveni, his historical involvement in the liberation struggle and his access to both establishment and opposition figures give him unusual capacity to initiate conversations about a post-Museveni political settlement. My analysis explicitly connects Saleh’s initiative to the question of who succeeds Museveni, how the transition occurs and what political arrangement follows. There are at least five possible strategic calculations behind his urgency: first, succession management-preventing a potentially destabilising contest over who inherits political power; second, regime preservation through political accommodation-broadening the legitimacy of the existing political order by bringing selected opposition actors into negotiated governance; third, historical reconciliation-addressing grievances that decades of military victory and electoral competition have not necessarily resolved; fourth, elite exit and generational transition-creating a framework through which the political generation that came to power in 1986 might negotiate its eventual departure; and fifth, conflict prevention-reducing the possibility that political exclusion, repression and polarisation could produce another national crisis. These are analytical interpretations, not proven statements of Saleh’s private intentions. Many question the timing of the initiative, particularly when the ruling establishment appears electorally dominant and the succession dimension as central to understanding Saleh’s political calculations.
The irony, however, is that a project presented as national reconciliation could become a sophisticated mechanism for negotiating the political survival of the establishment unless independent opposition forces and ordinary citizens genuinely shape its terms. Saleh may be seeking to negotiate tomorrow’s political architecture before tomorrow negotiates it for him. Ultimately, the critical question is not simply why he wants the CDA, but whether he is prepared to accept a settlement that genuinely redistributes political power, guarantees democratic competition and allows Uganda to move beyond personalised rule. As the African proverb goes, when the hunter begins consulting the animals about the future of the forest, the animals must ask whether he has come to plant trees or change hunting grounds.
Is General SS CDA the antidote to Uganda’s National malaise or just another cock crowing at dawn while the village remains in darkness?
Is General SS CDA the long-awaited political panacea capable of exorcising Uganda’s stubborn demons as pointed out in the CDA document: sectarianism, tribalism, nepotism, regionalism, ethnic chauvinism, political patronage, exclusion, marginalization, discrimination, historical injustices, institutionalized inequality, political persecution, corruption, impunity, cronyism, ideological intolerance, economic disenfranchisement, unequal resource allocation, selective justice, democratic deficits, identity-based politics, social fragmentation, elite capture, political vendettas, militarization of governance, abuse of authority, regional alienation, cultural prejudice, generational disillusionment and the poisonous politics of who belongs, who eats and who is left outside the national banquet? Or is it merely another political chameleon changing colours while occupying the same old tree of exclusion? Indeed, an African proverb reminds us that “When the roots of a tree begin to decay, the branches cannot remain healthy.” Uganda’s predicament is therefore not simply a crisis of personalities, but a deeply entrenched crisis of institutional architecture, political culture and distributive justice. General SS CDA must consequently prove whether it is a genuine instrument of national reconstruction or simply another beautifully packaged political mirage, where the language of unity becomes the perfume sprayed over the stench of inequality.But iam confident by age,profile of SS iam not sure he has plenty of time to play games like young man. As another African saying cautions, “A single bracelet does not jingle.” National cohesion cannot be manufactured through political slogans, ethnic arithmetic, ceremonial handshakes or choreographed patriotism; it must be cultivated through equitable representation, constitutionalism, meritocracy, accountability, inclusive governance, institutional independence and equal citizenship. Otherwise, replacing one circle of beneficiaries with another is merely sectarianism in a new political wardrobe a case of old wine masquerading in a new bottle? Can General SS CDA dismantle the architecture of exclusion, or will it simply inherit the keys to the same political mansion whose doors have historically remained locked against ordinary Ugandans? Will the marginalized finally have a seat at the table, or will they continue supplying the firewood while others feast around the cooking pot? Let it be remembered that a river does not drink its own water, a tree does not eat its own fruit, and a leader does not exist for himself. Uganda needs neither another political messiah nor an acronym inflated with revolutionary vocabulary; it needs a credible national transformation agenda that converts political belonging into equal opportunity, diversity into strength, and historical grievances into restorative justice. Ultimately, General SS CDA will not be judged by the thunder of its political rhetoric, the grandeur of its title or the number of drums beaten in the name of unity, but by whether the last excluded Ugandan can finally walk into the national house without knocking, begging or apologising for belonging.
Should Uganda throw the Baby away with the bathwater, or seize the opportunity to rewrite the National destiny? – From condemnation to Constructive Reconstruction!
Should Ugandans dismiss General SS CDA as another political masquerade because of the overwhelmingly negative sentiments circulating in online commentaries, or should we approach it with intellectual maturity, critical patriotism and constructive engagement, transforming it from a potentially imperfect document into a more credible blueprint for national reconciliation, inclusion and transformation? Surely, a nation cannot build its future by permanently imprisoning its present in the mistakes of its past. If a person who has sinned openly acknowledges wrongdoing, professes repentance and genuinely seeks forgiveness, should society eternally become an archive of his transgressions, or should it examine the sincerity of his repentance while allowing room for restitution and transformation? Christianity offers a profound lesson: “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins” (1 John 1:9), while Luke 15:7 reminds us that there is joy over one sinner who repents. Similarly, the Qur’an declares, “Do not despair of the mercy of Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives all sins” (Qur’an 39:53), and further teaches, “Repel [evil] by that [deed] which is better” (Qur’an 41:34). These spiritual teachings do not demand blind endorsement, erase accountability or prohibit scrutiny; rather, they illuminate the possibility of repentance, reconciliation, restitution and a second chance. By the same token, Ugandans should neither become political praise singers nor professional undertakers of every emerging initiative. Let us not turn the CDA into a political sacrificial lamb before interrogating its contents, nor crown it a national constitution before examining its weaknesses. The wise farmer does not burn an entire garden because some seedlings are crooked; he weeds, prunes, grafts and cultivates until the garden becomes productive. My considered position is that Ugandans should embrace constructive criticism rather than reflexive condemnation: interrogate the CDA, identify its ideological gaps, expose its ambiguities, challenge its omissions and submit hard-hitting, evidence-based and implementable recommendations on constitutionalism, multiparty democracy, national reconciliation, equitable regional representation, youth empowerment, women’s participation, institutional independence, civilian oversight, accountability, anti-corruption safeguards, economic justice, minority protection, transitional justice, decentralisation, land rights, historical grievances and the eradication of sectarian patronage. Let the Professor OO receive a national intellectual harvest from Ugandans and use those contributions to lipstick, eyebrow, refine, restructure and strengthen the document until its appearance is matched by substantive democratic beauty. After all, even a beautiful calabash must be inspected for cracks before it is entrusted with drinking water. An African proverb teaches that “If you want to go fast, go alone; if you want to go far, go together.” We must therefore move beyond the lazy binary of unconditional endorsement versus wholesale rejection. Criticism should be a chisel, not a hammer; dialogue should be a bridge, not a battlefield; and patriotism should be measured by the courage to correct, not the convenience of applauding. However, forgiveness must not become amnesia, repentance must be demonstrated through action, and national reconciliation must never be a disguise for impunity. Uganda does not need 80% condemnation, 20% applause or 100% political noise; it needs 100% serious national participation. Let us not merely ask whether the CDA deserves our approval; let us ask what concrete improvements would make it deserve the confidence of every Ugandan. The ultimate wisdom is simple: do not merely throw stones at the sculptor; bring better tools, sharper ideas and stronger designs so that together we can sculpt a national future worthy of generations yet unborn.
The national call to action: from political noise to national peace architecture
I therefore call upon General SS, Professor OO, security institutions, political parties, opposition leaders, constitutional lawyers, academics, cultural leaders, religious institutions, women, youth, entrepreneurs, civil society, professional associations, the Ugandan diaspora and ordinary citizens to turn this CDA controversy into a national opportunity for intellectual mobilisation and democratic renewal. Let us establish a transparent, independent and inclusive national feedback process through which Ugandans can interrogate every chapter, identify every loophole, challenge every assumption and propose practical alternatives. Let the Professor OO receive constructive criticism as intellectual fertiliser rather than political hostility, and let General SS demonstrate through concrete commitments that this initiative is bigger than individual political survival, succession arithmetic or regime preservation. The test is whether those who have historically occupied the corridors of power are prepared to share decision-making, submit to accountability and accept constitutional limits. We must not confuse forgiveness with forgetting, dialogue with surrender, reconciliation with impunity or power-sharing with power-hoarding wearing a democratic necktie.
Uganda needs a new social contract in which citizenship is not a presidential favour, national resources are not ethnic inheritance, public appointments are not political family property, and opportunity is not distributed according to proximity to the corridors of power. My appeal is simple: do not merely throw stones at the sculptor; bring better tools, sharper ideas, stronger constitutional safeguards and more inclusive designs. Let us not burn the peace laboratory before testing its instruments, but neither should we drink its medicine before examining its ingredients. Uganda must move from the politics of who captures the state to the politics of how the state serves everyone. The ultimate national question is not whether General SS and Professor OO deserve applause or condemnation; it is whether their proposed CDA can withstand public scrutiny, constitutional examination and the uncompromising demands of democratic legitimacy. Our collective responsibility is to ensure that the next chapter of Uganda’s history is not another contest over who inherits the national throne, but a historic transformation of the national house into a home for all.
The National Message: Let us not just condemn the CDA, let us correct it; not just question the architects, but demand better architecture; not just scramble for peace, but build a just, accountable and lasting peace.
Dr. Opul Joseph, PhD
Lecturer, Gulu University and Chief, Kitgum Campus
Founder, Quality Education Consultancy Ltd (QECL)
CEO, OPUL Skilling Foundation Africa (OSFA)
President, Rotary Club of Soroti Central
Life Member, Uganda Red Cross Society
Email: [email protected]
The post Dr. Opul Joseph, PhD: The scramble for peace laboratory: What exactly is troubling General Salim Saleh (SS) now after 40 years in political high table? appeared first on Watchdog Uganda.

