A senior lawyer and chieftain of the Nigeria Democratic Congress, NDC, Okenna Peter Agubuzu, esq., has condemned the appeal filed by the Nigerian government challenging a court judgment which ordered the United Kingdom to pay £420 million compensation to the relatives of the 21 coal miners who were gunned down by the colonial police during the 1949 Iva Valley Massacre.
The judgment delivered by Justice Anthony Onovo of the Enugu High Court on February 5, 2026, held the British government liable for the killing of the 21 coal miners while they were protesting harsh working conditions and racial discrimination at the Iva Valley Coal Mines in Enugu.
Ruling in the suit numbered E/909/2024, brought by an activist, Mazi Greg Onoh, against Secretary of State for the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, FCDO, British government and four other respondents, Justice Onovo ordered the UK government to pay £20 million to each of the 21 families (totaling £420 million) and issue a formal apology for the massacre.
The judge further held that the Federal Government and the Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, AGF, both joined as 3rd and 4th respondents in the matter, had a constitutional responsibility under Section 19 (d) and 150 (1) of the 1999 Constitution to pursue justice and diplomatic engagement for the families of the victims.
Reacting to the appeal filed by the Federal Government against the landmark judgment, Agubuzu accused the Bola Tinubu-led All Progressives Congress, APC, administration of demonstrating insensitivity to the unprecedented hardship that the generations of the coal miners had passed through since they lost their breadwinners almost eight decades ago.
According to the NDC chieftain, the appeal filed by the Federal Government through the AGF equally raises the broader question of the poor treatment of Nigerians by the Tinubu administration from its inception in May 2023.
He said, “The appeal filed by the AGF is quite curious and regrettable. Whose interest is the AGF protecting? Is he protecting the interest of Nigerians or United Kingdom? Is it the duty of the Nigerian Government to appeal against a judgment awarded in favour of Nigerians, against ill mannered colonialists?
“It is unfortunate and regrettable that the Tinubu Government chose to protect the interest of the United Kingdom, rather than allow them to honour the judgment or appeal."
Speaking further, Agubuzu wondered why the Federal Government cried more than the bereaved instead of complying, especially when the 1999 Constitution mandated the President to defend, pursue justice and secure recompense for relatives of the protesting 21 coal miners killed by the British colonial administration.
He drew a parallel between the position taken by the Nigerian government on the judgment and the tacit support given by the Kenyan government to the case for compensation for victims of British colonial abuses during the Mau Mau uprising in Kenya in the 1950s.
He recalled that in 2010, the Kenyan government through its Ministry of Foreign Affairs declared its “full support” for the claimants’ lawsuits in British courts while rejecting any suggestion that the Kenyan Republic inherited legal liability for British colonial abuses.
“In a diplomatic push on October 12, 2012, the then Kenyan Prime Minister, Raila Odinga, wrote to the British Prime Minister, David Cameron, urging the resolution of the issue. In June 2013, the UK government agreed to a £19.9 million settlement, covering 5,228 claimants, expressed ‘sincere regrets’ over the torture and ill treatment, and pledged support for a memorial in Nairobi for the victims,” Agubuzu said.
Consequently, the NDC chieftain called on the Nigerian government to take a cue from its Kenyan counterpart and quickly withdraw its appeal challenging the court judgment ordering the UK to pay £420 million compensation to the relatives of the 21 coal miners who died during the 1949 Iva Valley Massacre.
As of the time of writing this report, the AGF has not stated any grounds for appealing against the judgment.
The Iva Valley Massacre, also known as the Enugu Colliery Massacre, occurred on November 18, 1949 in Enugu, when colonial police opened fire on striking coal miners at Iva Valley Coal Mines, killing 21 coal miners and injuring 51 others.
The killings caused widespread outrage across Nigeria and helped unite labour unions and nationalist groups, accelerating momentum towards Nigeria’s independence in 1960.
Iva Valley massacre: NDC chieftain condemns FG's appeal against £420m UK compensation ruling

