“It is the first step to taxation with representation to provide that taxation should be accompanied by understanding,” John Buchan.
An alternative title to this article could be “Taxation, Citizenship and the Making of the State”, because the issues involved centre fundamentally on the relationship between the state and the citizen in the collection and use of public revenue. I recently read David Womersley’s short treatise, What Counts as Taxation?, published on September 27, 2016, and it set me thinking about taxation in Nigeria in ways that go considerably beyond rates, percentages, assessments, exemptions and revenue targets. Womersley was writing in another historical and intellectual context, but the simplicity of his question is deceptive. What, indeed, counts as taxation?
Call it tax, duty, impost, customs charge, excise, stamp duty, royalty, levy, rate, licence fee, value added tax or some other statutory payment; the essential character remains recognisable. The state, acting under the authority of law, requires the citizen, enterprise or economic transaction to surrender a portion of income, property or value for purposes determined by public authority. Unlike most ordinary economic exchanges, the transaction is not voluntary.
That compulsory character should make taxation one of the most important subjects in any serious discussion about the state, its characteristics and reason for existence. A shopkeeper cannot force us to buy his merchandise. A bank cannot compel us to deposit money with it. A restaurant cannot require us to eat its food. Yet the state can lawfully demand taxes and impose consequences for failure to pay. Taxation is therefore not merely an accounting exercise conducted somewhere inside ministries of finance and revenue agencies. It is one of the clearest expressions of state power, legitimacy and authority.
If this is so, perhaps we have traditionally looked at taxation in Nigeria from the wrong end. Instead of regarding it as merely one among many peripheral activities of government, should we not organise a much larger part of our understanding of government around it? If the state is empowered to take compulsory contributions from citizens, then its structures, laws, expenditures, obligations and standards of accountability should logically be shaped by the responsibilities arising from that extraordinary power.
This question is hardly new in Africa. More than a century ago, John Buchan, in his book The African Colony, reflected upon taxation in colonial South Africa. He discussed hut taxes, poll taxes, customs duties and the taxable capacity of African populations. He also considered the possibility of consolidating various native taxes and directing taxation towards what colonial administrators regarded as untapped economic capacity.
We must, of course, recognise the colonial assumptions within which Buchan was writing. Africans were not being treated as sovereign citizens participating equally in determining the purposes of government. Taxation could be viewed from above as an instrument for financing administration, ordering society and influencing economic behaviour.
Yet Buchan leaves us with a question that remains highly relevant today: by what standard does a government decide that its people can bear additional taxation?
Is taxable capacity merely the existence of income from which government can extract something, or must government consider the total burdens already carried by the citizen? A person may possess an income and therefore appear taxable on paper. But what if that person must privately finance electricity, water, transportation, healthcare, education and security? How much of what appears to government as taxable capacity has already been committed to compensating for deficiencies in public services?
This is where another colonial-era writer, E. D. Morel, becomes even more interesting for Nigerians. In his book Nigeria: Its Peoples and Its Problems, published in 1911, Morel devoted considerable attention to taxation and public finance in territories shortly afterwards amalgamated into modern Nigeria. He distinguished between established systems of direct taxation in the Emirates of Northern Nigeria and the more delicate question of introducing similar taxation in parts of Southern Nigeria.
In the North, Morel described taxation as already embedded within indigenous administrative arrangements. Village communities formed important units of assessment, while obligations reflected occupations, property, agriculture, livestock and other forms of economic activity. He regarded more regularised direct taxation as an important element in constructing viable administration.
But what is particularly instructive is that Morel did not discuss revenue only in terms of collection. He connected it with expenditure. He envisaged revenues supporting local officials, public works, sanitation, economic investigation and other requirements of administration and development. More than one hundred years ago, therefore, before Nigeria existed in its present constitutional form, taxation was already being discussed alongside the equally important question of what government should do with the proceeds.
Morel was also cautious about introducing direct taxation where it had not previously existed. In parts of Southern Nigeria, he recognised that communities long accustomed to dealing with British authorities without paying tribute could not simply be subjected overnight to a new fiscal order without political consequences. He advocated gradual approaches and acknowledged the importance of existing institutions and customary arrangements.
Behind all this lies an enduring principle: taxation requires legitimacy. The authority to collect may be established by law, but durable taxation requires more than coercion. People must understand why they are being taxed, by whom, for what purpose and with what consequences for their lives.
If this principle mattered under colonial government, it should matter infinitely more under democratic government today. There is a profound difference between taxing subjects and taxing citizens. The colonial subject could be compelled to contribute towards an administration over whose ultimate direction he possessed little control. The democratic citizen, on the other hand, is theoretically a participant in sovereignty itself. He elects governments, finances public institutions and is entitled to demand accountability from those exercising power in his name.
The famous principle of “no taxation without representation” was therefore never simply about hostility to payment. It expressed the deeper proposition that whoever possesses the power to take resources from the people must also be answerable to the same people who paid the taxes.
Nigeria’s subsequent political economy complicated this relationship. The discovery and eventual dominance of petroleum revenues created a state financed for decades substantially by income derived from a natural resource rather than directly and visibly from the pockets and productive activities of most citizens. Government became preoccupied with revenues accruing from oil and their distribution among the different levels of the federation.
The political vocabulary itself reflected this reality. Governments waited for allocations. States measured their fortunes partly by what came from the centre. Political arguments revolved around revenue sharing, derivation and entitlement. Under such circumstances, the relationship between taxpayer and government gradually became tenuous.
Where a state depends heavily upon revenues obtained independently of citizens’ everyday productive activities, government may feel less direct pressure to nurture their productivity. Conversely, citizens who do not consciously experience themselves as the principal financiers of government may feel less urgency in interrogating public expenditure.
A taxation state creates a different political psychology. If government increasingly depends upon citizens’ incomes, consumption, property, enterprises and transactions, then citizens acquire a heightened interest in the cost and performance of government. The taxpayer begins to ask inconvenient but legitimate questions: Who collected this money? By what authority? How much was collected? Where was it deposited? Who appropriated it? Who spent it? What was it spent upon? Who audited the expenditure? Who is responsible for its safety?
Most importantly, what physical or documentary evidence exists that the money created the public value for which it was supposedly taken? These are not acts of rebellion against government. They are acts of responsible citizenship and sources of governmental legitimacy.
There should therefore be an almost symmetrical relationship between the obligations of taxpayer and government. If citizens must maintain records, make declarations, submit returns, explain transactions and prove compliance, then government should be equally capable of demonstrating what it collected and what became of the money afterwards.
Taxation should create a traceable public chain involving collection, receipt, appropriation, expenditure, delivery, audit, accountability and reporting. The citizen should not disappear from that chain once his money has been collected.
This brings us to the central proposition of this series. Nigeria is attempting, whether by necessity or deliberate policy, to broaden the role of taxation in financing government and sustaining the economy. That transition cannot be treated merely as a technical fiscal exercise. It represents a potential restructuring of the relationship between the Nigerian state, Nigerian society and the Nigerian citizen.
If government expects more from citizens, citizens must expect more from government. If the state becomes more efficient at identifying taxable income, it must become equally efficient at identifying waste and curbing excess. If it demands greater compliance, it must demonstrate greater prudence, accountability and service delivery.
More than a century has passed since Buchan and Morel debated African taxable capacity, direct taxation, customs revenues, provincial finances and public works. Nigeria has since become independent, republican, federal and democratic. The institutions have changed, and the status of the people has changed from colonial subjects to citizens of an independent nation.
However, one fundamental question remains remarkably persistent: what does the state owe the citizen after collecting his money? Until that question is satisfactorily answered, another will continue to follow closely behind it: When does taxation cease to represent a contribution towards the common good and begin instead to resemble an imposition?
That is where the Nigerian taxpayer enters the story, and where the next instalment leads us.
The post Taxation or imposition?: The state, economy and citizenship in Nigeria (1), by Usman Sarki appeared first on Vanguard News.

